How to Choose Good-Quality Canned Tuna
How to choose good-quality canned tuna: the species, cut, catch method, sodium and label checks that separate premium tuna from cheap filler.
How To Choose Good-Quality Canned Tuna
Head to the canned fish aisle in any Australian supermarket, and you’ll find tins that look almost identical, with similar price ranges and labelling.
So how can you choose good-quality canned tuna when faced with so many choices? The answer is: what’s on the tin’s label can tell you a lot about what’s in the can. Knowing the criteria and how to read the label can help you pick out premium canned tuna in less than 30 seconds.
Let’s dive deeper into how to find the best-quality can of tuna on your supermarket shelf that’s also good value for money.
Quick Answer: What Makes A Can Of Tuna Good Quality?
When you’re trying to find the best canned tuna on your supermarket shelf, check for:
- Type of species: Canned tuna using Yellowfin tuna (Thunnus albacares) is a premium fish, with a pale, firmer, milder-tasting flesh vs. skipjack tuna with a stronger, bolder taste and lower cost.
- Cut of tuna: Is it whole fillets, solid chunks or shredded flakes and offcuts?
- Packing liquid: Premium olive oil, premium oil blends, or springwater helps preserve the natural flavour of the fish. Generic vegetable oil or heavy brine can impact the taste
- Catch method: Pole-and-line caught tuna is considered the most sustainable method with minimal bycatch that protects marine life while preventing fish from bruising, for better-quality meat. Additionally, this method also reduces plastic waste into the oceans.
- Fat and lighter canned tuna options: Tuna is naturally lean, but fat levels on the label vary. Higher fat usually comes from added packing oil, though some species and belly cuts are naturally richer in healthy fats.
- Drained weight: Measures actual fish meat, excluding liquid. Choose a higher drained weight to get more fish for your money.
Sirena’s canned tuna range uses only chunky Yellowfin tuna (Thunnus albacares), caught sustainably by pole-and-line, and is packed in a premium olive oil blend or springwater versions.
1. Species: Yellowfin vs Skipjack
The type of species used in canned tuna is the single most important indicator of quality. It’s also one that most shoppers don’t know about or check.
Yellowfin tuna is a premium fish and has a mild, clean flavour and a firm, meaty texture that holds its shape in the can. Skipjack tuna (Katsuwonus pelamis) has a bolder, stronger flavour and softer texture. It makes up the majority of the global canned tuna market as it’s a cheaper species.
If you’re using canned tuna as the main ingredient in salads, pasta, or rice bowls, the type of species you choose will affect the taste of your dish. Read Types of Tuna Explained: From Skipjack to Yellowfin to know how they compare.
2. Cut and Form: Fillets, Chunks or Flakes
Whole fillets and solid chunks are a prime cut, while flakes and shredded tuna are typically processed offcuts. How can you tell if it’s a premium cut? Tip a can of tuna onto a plate, and the contents will hold together. If it’s a soft, wet mass of shredded fish, it means the canned tuna is made from offcuts.
3. Packing Liquid
If you prefer a clean and neutral-tasting canned tuna for cooking, choose the springwater version.
A quality oil adds richness and works with the tuna’s natural flavour instead of smothering or altering it. Avoid canned tuna with generic vegetable oil, as it’s a cheap filler, and heavy brine. The added salt masks the fish’s taste instead of complementing it.
Sirena’s canned tuna varieties come packed in a unique olive oil blend, extra virgin olive oil or springwater, labelled clearly on the cans. Want the best of both worlds? Sirena’s LITE range combines springwater with a dash of our signature Italian extra virgin olive oil—delivering the rich flavour you know and love with 96% less fat.
Read Springwater vs. Oil: Which Canned Tuna Should You Use for Your Recipe?
4. Fat And Lighter Canned Tuna Options
Compare fat content per 100g rather than per serving, as serve sizes vary widely between brands. However, a lower fat number on the label doesn’t automatically mean a healthier or better product—it comes down to the type of fat.
Tuna contains virtually no trans or saturated fats, offering mostly heart-healthy monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fats (including essential omega-3s). Tuna packed in springwater is naturally lower in total fat than tuna packed in olive oil, but quality packing oil adds richness and beneficial unsaturated fats.
For those who want a nutritious, low-calorie option without sacrificing flavour, Sirena’s LITE range is 96% fat-free—blending springwater, sea salt, and our signature Italian olive oil for the ultimate taste and balance.
5. Catch Method: Pole-and-Line vs Nets
The type of fishing method used to catch the tuna in your can says a lot about the product’s sustainability and quality.
The pole-and-line method catches one tuna at a time using a single rod and barbless hook and is seen as more sustainable compared to other commercial fishing methods. By handling each fish individually, it prevents the net-crushing and bruising caused by heavy industrial nets—delivering a firmer fillet with better texture and flavour.
Purse seine fishing uses large nets that capture high volumes of fish at once. This squeezes hundreds of fish together, damaging the meat’s texture, leading to higher bycatch rates and little control over which species or sizes are caught. Sustainability is one of Sirena’s core values. That’s why we use pole-and-line caught tuna in our cans. We are also a proud member of the International Pole and Line Foundation (IPNLF).
Read more about Why Pole and Line Matters: Sirena’s Commitment to Sustainable Tuna
6. Drained Weight and Fish-to-Liquid Ratio
The total weight of canned tuna also includes packing liquid.
The drained weight shows how much actual fish you get once the liquid has been drained. Drained weight needs to be declared on the label; however, it varies considerably between brands. A lower drained weight means you’re paying more for the liquid inside the can, not the fish quantity. Don’t be fooled by the visual volume inside the can either; chunk tuna naturally packs together more tightly and looks more compact than flaky tuna, even when the actual weight of the fish is the same.
The 30-Second At-Home Quality Check
When you open a quality can of tuna, you should see fish that’s firm, pale to medium pink in colour, and holds its shape when lifted. It should also have a mild, clean smell with clear liquid. Soft, mushy pieces, an overpowering fishy smell, or a can filled mostly with liquid are signs of low-quality canned tuna.
What To Do Next
Keep this checklist handy for the next time you go to the shops. It takes about 30 seconds and changes what ends up on your plate.
Explore the Sirena range here, including our lighter options.
Sources
- Eat for Health (NHMRC). (July 13, 2017). Nutrient Reference Values: Sodium. Retrieved 10 August 2026, from https://www.eatforhealth.gov.au/nutrient-reference-values/nutrients/sodium
- Food Standards Australia New Zealand (November 26, 2025). Retrieved 10 August 2026, from https://www.foodstandards.gov.au/consumer/nutrition/sodium-salt/salthowmuch
- Food Standards Australia New Zealand. (December 13, 2020). Mercury in fish. Retrieved 10 August 2026, from https://www.foodstandards.gov.au/consumer/chemicals/mercury
- Food Standards Australia New Zealand. (December 13, 2020). Mercury in fish brochure. Retrieved 10 August 2026, from https://www.foodstandards.gov.au/sites/default/files/consumer/chemicals/mercury/Documents/Mercury%20in%20Fish%20brochure%20Dec%202020%20Final.pdf
- International Pole and Line Foundation (IPNLF). Retrieved 10 August 2026, from https://ipnlf.org
